Top

What Is Gamma

Sunday, 11 May 2008, 12:36 am GMT  

… and why is it important. Many HDTVs will have a control, often tucked away under advanced settings in a picture settings menu, labelled gamma. User manuals are often unhelpful in explaining what the gamma control does and even the better ones may be less than specific with terms such as “adjusts the balance between bright and dark areas of the picture”. To know how to adjust the gamma control we need to know what it does and why, so read on.

Gamma is actually a throw-back to the days of CRT televisions. Look at the graph below which plots incoming signal level versus light output of a typical CRT TV.

Gamma Graph

Notice how an input voltage of 50% produces only 18% of maximum brightness. This non-linear relationship between input voltage and output brightness is inherent in CRT technology.

To correct this “defect” an inverse gamma curve, like the one below, is applied to the source material.

Inverse Gamma

Combine the “corrected” input gamma black line and the “broken” CRT gamma red line and the result is a linear relationship between input and output (the yellow line).

Gamma Correction

So that was how it worked on a CRT TV!

Fast forward to flat screen displays and what do we find? Plasmas and LCD displays don’t behave like CRT screens – they are inherently linear devices – but the source material is all being corrected for the old CRT displays so there is a big problem. What we now need is to make the flat panel HDTVs behave as if they were CRT devices and this is what the gamma control should do. We need to turn the yellow line into the black curve.

A gamma setting of 2.2 is usually considered the ideal setting and though some manufacturers offer adjustments with choices such as 2.0, 2.2, 2.5 etc. selecting 2.2 doesn’t necessarily guarantee that 2.2 is what you get. The only way to be sure is to measure the display’s output with a video analyzer and doing so is an essential part of an ISF calibration.

In the absence of a video analyzer can it be done by eye? Possibly, but you need to know what to look for! If gamma is set too low the picture will appear to be “washed out” whereas if set too high shadow detail close to black will be lacking.

The user manual that advised that the gamma control “adjusts the balance between bright and dark areas of the picture” tells the truth but isn”t too helpful. One more graph may help:

Different gamma settings

Big differences are apparent on the graph in the mid range (30 � 70 % input voltage). What does this mean in practice? Here are three screen captures, with gamma set to low (e.g. 1.5), normal (e.g. 2.2) and high (e.g. 3.0).

Photo of low gamma
Example photo of low gamma (e.g. 1.5)
Photo of normal gamma
Example photo of normal gamma (e.g. 2.2)
Photo of high gamma
Example photo of high gamma (e.g. 3.0)

Look at the mid range first. Low gamma (e.g. 1.5) produces a picture that looks “milky”, it looks flat and lacks punch. High gamma (e.g. 3.0) has loads of punch but now look at detail in the black areas – it has gone. Normal gamma (e.g. 2.2) gets the black detail and a picture that is crisp.

Setting gamma correctly is just one part of accurately calibrating an HDTV but it is an important part.

Piers Clerk
ISF Calibrator
www.homecinemaengineering.com

© Home Cinema Engineering Ltd. 2008

4 Comments So Far... Add Yours

  1. Dr. Sheldon Tarre on 12 May 2008 1:38 pm

    I would have expected that gamma 1.5 would have given the best results as it is closest to the diagonal. Why is this not the case? Thank you!

  2. Niclas on 13 May 2008 8:20 pm

    Because the set display gamma in combination with the source gamma is what combined makes out the final gamma, see picture “FInal Display”.
    And the last picture only shows curves for the set display gamma, 1,5, 2,2 and 3,0. And if you put those curves into the final gamma-picture you´ll see that in combination with the source gamma curve the 2,2- curve will lead to the most diagonal final curve summed up.

  3. pacman on 14 May 2008 10:41 am

    Nice, easy to understand, article about this often miss-understood subject.

    To put what Nicklas said in anorther way:
    Systemgamma (”final gamma”) = sourcegamma * displaygamma
    The source gamma is 0.45 (except near black), according to the tv-standards. With a displaygamma of 2.2 we get 0.45*2.2 = 1.0.

    The “1.0″ suggest that the image we see is exactly the “same” as the original, hence 2.2 is regarded as correct by many. But not all, including me, and there are good reasons for that - but for now lets just say that 2.2 from black to white is ALOT better then almost ALL displays when thay are set as “out-of-the-box” ;).

    (”out-of-the-box” many displays confirm to a s-shaped gamma curve which in dark parts are more like 3.0 above and in light parts more like 1.5 to look much more “punchy” and more contrast-rich - the result is an image that look totaly unnatural that lacks detail just about everywhere)

    For readers who might want to now more about subject, I recommend:
    http://www.poynton.com/GammaFAQ.html

  4. Panasonic TH42PZ80 / TH42PZ80B Review: 42" Viera Plasma HDTV on 14 May 2008 12:11 pm

    [...] our recent “What Is Gamma” article, we thought it’d be enlightening to include the gamma graphs of the Panasonic [...]

Add your comment here





Bottom